ConfitaConfita comparisons · Verified November 6, 2026
MyCustomBakes (My Custom Bakes) is a one-plan order manager for US bakers who quote most orders. Confita is a storefront that checks out everyday products instantly and keeps custom work, deposits and drops in the same shop.
Join 250+ bakers on Confita
you sell in the US and want the order manager to do everything.
the storefront is what sells.
The difference
Neither takes a cut of your sales. The difference is where the order starts and where you can sell.
| What changes | Confita | MyCustomBakes |
|---|---|---|
| Plan price | US$9.99/month or US$49/year | US$10/month or US$110/year, one plan with every feature |
| Free trial | 7 days, card on file | 30 days; its FAQ says a card is required |
| Fees on your sales | 0% from Confita on your own Stripe or Square (Confita Payments: 3.9% + 30¢ all-in) | No transaction fees; Square’s processing rate applies |
| Card payments | Your own Square or Stripe, or Confita Payments with no account needed (US and Canada) | Your own Square account; Stripe announced for Canada |
| From browse to order | Instant checkout for products; questions, private quote, deposit and balance for custom work | Order form and a quote you approve; Direct Checkout for fixed-price items |
| Limited releases | Scheduled drops with cutoffs, pickup windows, and capacity | Presales with set pickup dates and locations, plus class tickets |
| Storefront design | All themes included, with fonts, banners, custom stickers, motion, and brand controls | Semi-customizable shopfront with a custom URL |
| Where it works | Storefronts in English and Spanish; cards where Square or Stripe operate | United States only for now; Canada announced |
| Back office | Order inbox, sales view, and private status page | Chat center, automated reminders, packing slips, tax settings, production planner |
A shop built to sell
A dozen cookies with a fixed price can check out straight from your storefront. A tiered cake can ask for the date, servings, flavors and a reference photo first, then move to a private quote with a deposit.
MyCustomBakes may be the better fit when the order manager is the center. Confita is the fit when the storefront is.
Before you choose
What bakers ask about MyCustomBakes and Confita
Reviewed against MyCustomBakes’ pricing, FAQ and help center on November 6, 2026. Confirm current terms before subscribing.
MyCustomBakes is US$10/month or US$110/year, one plan with every feature. Every new subscription starts with a 30-day free trial, and its FAQ says the trial needs a credit card. It had a free tier from 2021 to 2024; that tier has ended. Confita is US$9.99/month or US$49/year after a 7-day free trial (checked November 6, 2026).
No. MyCustomBakes says it takes no percentage of your sales and charges no transaction fees. Card payments go through your own Square account, and Square’s processing rate goes to Square. Confita also adds 0% on your own Stripe or Square; Confita Payments, which needs neither account, is 3.9% + 30¢ all-in.
Not yet. Its FAQ says it currently serves bakers in the United States, and its alternatives page says Canada is coming soon. Confita storefronts work in English and Spanish; card payments depend on Square or Stripe operating in your country, and in Mexico you can connect Stripe or take SPEI and OXXO Pay manually.
Confita. Its storefronts, order flow and customer pages work in Spanish, and Mexico has its own plans in pesos. MyCustomBakes does not list a Spanish storefront on its public pages.
Not inside the plan. MyCustomBakes offers free web tools, including a recipe cost calculator and pricing calculators, and includes a weekly production planner with the subscription. Confita is not a recipe-costing system either; its free cake and bakery pricing calculators work without an account.
Before you switch
Still deciding about MyCustomBakes?
See how the workflow feels
Set up your products, add the details you need, and send yourself a test order before you share the link.
